Saint Michael's College

Dick Zeitler	1957-58	United Press International Small College All-America (2nd Team)
Tony Nicodemo	1958-59	Associated Press All-America (2nd Team)
Tony Nicodemo		United Press International Small College All-America (2nd Team)
Walter Baumann	1962-63	The Tablet Catholic Small College All-America (Honorable Mention)
Walter Baumann		United Press International Small College All-America (Honorable Mention)
Rich Tarrant	1963-64	The Tablet Catholic Small College All-America (1st Team)
Rich Tarrant		United Press International Small College All-America (2nd Team)
Rich Tarrant	1964-65	Associated Press Small College All-America (1st Team)
Rich Tarrant		United Press International Small College All-America (2nd Team)
Dick Falkenbush	1965-66	The Tablet Catholic Small College All-America (Honorable Mention)
Dick Falkenbush	1966-67	United Press International All-America (4th Team)
Fran Laffin	1973-74	National Association of Basketball Coaches All-America (2nd Team)
Ken Johnson	1975-76	National Association of Basketball Coaches All-America (2nd Team)
Tom Hoey	1978-79	National Association of Basketball Coaches All-America
George Daway	1987-88	Off the Glass Magazine All-America (1st Team)
George Daway		National Association of Basketball Coaches All-America (Honorable Mention)
George Daway		United Press International All-America (Honorable Mention)
Greg Thomas	1989-90	The Basketball Gazette All-America (Honorable Mention)
Mark Mulvey	1996-97	Division II Bulletin All-America (Honorable Mention)
Mark Mulvey		Street & Smith Magazine All-America (Honorable Mention)
Todd Roberts	2000-01	National Association of Basketball Coaches All-America (2nd Team)
Todd Roberts		Daktronics All-America (3rd Team)